"At one point, I visited a children's day fair and found myself sitting alongside a rival politician. He was grasping a bundle of 100 baht notes to distribute to the children, while I had come with nothing. How was I supposed to vie with that?"
The politician Chutiphong was a member of the "idealistic tide" of idealistic young candidates who surprised Thailand in the 2023 election by winning more seats for the forward-thinking movement than any rival party.
This year though, he was defeated in his seat in his electoral district of Rayong to a challenger from an long-standing political dynasty which has traditionally held influential posts there.
"In 2023 we were like a storm that overwhelmed and the established groups weren't ready to respond. They believed I was merely a unknown candidate. The wave of support for Move Forward in the last phase of that election really motivated voters to opt for something new."
Now renamed the People's Party, their hopes that they would build upon their previous results were shattered on the shoals of old-style patronage networks which have governed regional politics in Thailand during its modern history.
The outcomes are still not finalized, and a number of election irregularities are being investigated, but that cannot reverse the broad result: a dramatic drop of in excess of 20% in the total of seats won by the People's Party, and a notable surge by the conservative Bhumjaithai party, expanding its portion of seats from 71 in 2023 to an estimated 193 in the five-hundred-member parliament this year.
'They never speak with me anymore'
After securing his seat in 2023, Chutiphong threw himself into his role as MP, visiting his constituency hoping to help solve the problems faced by his constituents. But he rapidly encountered pushback from those working for the entrenched political operators. Moreover, he discovered he was pressured to provide financial support, from money he just did not have.
"An invitation was extended to me to a women's rights event - a frequent function for the locals to participate in and have fun. But they told me if I wanted to come, I needed to give 25,000 baht. I explained I didn't have that money. They were quite displeased about that and claimed I was cold-hearted. I inquired if there was another way I could do to help out. But they ceased communicating with me again."
What he had run up against was a entrenched structure of patronage controlled by a particular family.
Rayong is most famous as part of the Eastern Economic Corridor, Thailand's largest economic area, housing many of the industrial facilities which drive its export-dependent economy. This has brought in migrant workers from other regions, and also led to an urban middle class which is more open to the progressive policies of the reformist groups.
In 2023, Move Forward won all five electoral districts there.
But much of Rayong is still agricultural, home to agricultural workers and orchard owners. This is especially the case in District 4, where Chutipong secured his seat. He is a area resident, but spent several years based in California. The province has for a long time been dominated by a single powerful clan, the Pitutecha family. This is what is known in Thailand as "Baan Yai" – large household – politics, and throughout the country it is the method regional influence has always been managed.
Pitutechas manage much of the regional authority.
Piya 'Chang' Pitutecha, the sitting family head, is the elected head of the Provincial Administration Organisation (PAO), a hugely important position as the PAO controls the bulk of official budgets in Rayong.
Until 2023, Pitutechas had consistently been among the MPs voted to parliament, with one being the vice-minister for health in Bangkok.
Similar to other "Big House" families they have no fixed allegiance – through the years they have stood for several political parties. They are also prominent in the local business community, and, unlike Chutipong, have substantial financial resources to distribute. It was almost impossible for the rookie MP to compete.
The "Big House" rely on extensive webs of local agents - community members who know their neighbourhoods, and who organize voters to vote for their candidate. And while it is officially forbidden, they also distribute money during and after elections. They have historically been critical to the electoral performance of local politicians, and as a novel, largely city-based movement, the People's Party had did not possess them.
"Therefore I adjusted my approach," explains Chutipong. "I declared that I would attempt to address all complaints promptly. If your water doesn't run, your electricity has failed, your road has craters, I would be there."
"But the villagers who called me in then encountered pressure from the network. Some were attacked in the village's chat group or through the PA system in the village. They were charged of bringing me - an outsider they said - into the area."
"On occasions when I tried to visit factories after hearing some allegations about environmental damage, I met with a hostile response from local communities because they had been accepting packets from these factories."
When it came to the recent electoral contest, the Pitutechas had adapted after their setback in the prior election.
In those electoral areas, they fielded younger members of the family, more qualified and with a reduced patriarchal aura than the senior members. In District 3 they ran under the Democrat party, traditionally their chosen political partner, but in District 4, thirty-four-year-old Chatchai Pitutecha stood under Prime Minister Anutin Charvirakul's Bhumjaithai party, famous for its deep pockets and its ability in recruiting "Baan Yai" for his side.
Chutipong was overwhelmed.
The Pitutechas won those positions back from the People's Party, even though the progressives held onto three seats in Rayong.
"They would have accepted me if I had given them money, but I could not do that permanently given my modest means. I had to determine whether I would be the representative they expected, or if I would maintain my ideals and test if the constituents would